Alabama How the "Pro-Life" Movement Puts Women Behind Bars

People Demanding Action Radio Network

Banner

PregnantWomanNumerous organizations and leaders who identify themselves as pro-life have assured the public that their efforts to re-criminalize abortion and establish the unborn as separate legal persons will not result in the prosecution and imprisonment of women. Yet, in Alabama alone, the claim that eggs, embryos and fetuses have separate legal rights has provided the basis for arresting approximately 60 women.

These women are being prosecuted under Alabama’s 2006 law designed to provide special penalties for people who bring children into methamphetamine laboratories. Its official title is "Endangerment of Exposing a Child to an Environment in Which Controlled Substances are Produced or Distributed" and it provides that a person “commits the crime of chemical endangerment” by “exposing a child to an environment in which he or she...knowingly, recklessly, or intentionally causes or permits a child to be exposed to, to ingest or inhale, or to have contact with a controlled substance.”

This law makes no mention of pregnancy, pregnant woman, drug use, fetus, or any other words that would make it applicable to a pregnant woman who uses a controlled substance and seeks to continue her pregnancy to term. In fact, the Alabama legislature has repeatedly refused to amend this law or to create others that would address the issue of pregnancy and drug use through the criminal law.

Nevertheless prosecutors have argued, and the Alabama’s Court of Criminal Appeals has agreed, that the word “child” in the statute includes a “viable fetus” and therefore may be used to arrest and jail women who become pregnant, eschew abortion, go to term, and try to bring life into this world, despite having used a controlled substance.

The Appeals Court decision reaches far beyond women who use illegal drugs or even drug use at all. Many prescription drugs are controlled substances and there is no defense under the law if the drug is prescribed to the pregnant woman. This means that a pregnant woman who is prescribed a controlled substance (and her doctor who prescribed it) are now potentially subject to criminal penalties as well. And, if the word “child” in one Alabama criminal laws means “viable fetus,” then surely it would have to mean the same thing in others – including the state’s child abuse and related laws. This means that women are potentially criminally liable for an unlimited range of actions, inactions or circumstances during pregnancy believed by police and prosecutors to pose a risk of harm to the fetus. (Think “personhood” measure in disguise.)

Hope Ankrom and Amanda Kimbrough are two of the 60 women who have been charged under the chemical endangering law – not for running meth labs or bringing children to them, but rather for continuing their pregnancies to term in spite of having a drug problem. Ankrom and Kimbrough have appealed their convictions to the Alabama Supreme Court.

Forty-seven medical, public health and legal advocacy groups and individuals, including the American Medical Association, the American Psychiatric Association, the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists, and the American Nurses Association filed an amicus (friend of the court) brief in support of these mothers. They urge the court to reverse the lower court’s radical extension of the chemical endangering law to permit prosecution and punishment of new mothers, pregnant women, and their doctors.

These organizations and experts explain that while they do not in any way endorse the use of illegal drugs during pregnancy, medical consensus is that illegal drug use by pregnant women does not pose risks qualitatively different or greater than a wide range of other actions, inactions, exposures, and circumstances engaged in or experienced by pregnant women, such as smoking cigarettes.

They also agree that using the criminal law to address issues of drug use during pregnancy undermines maternal and fetal health by deterring pregnant women from drug treatment, prenatal care, healthcare, and labor and delivery services during pregnancy, which are beneficial to maternal, fetal and child health. Furthermore, these experts maintain that if the lower court opinion is upheld, pregnant women who cannot overcome an addiction in the short term of pregnancy will be encouraged to have unwanted abortions to avoid criminal penalties.

It seems odd then that Marshall County Alabama prosecutor Mitch Floyd, who brings these prosecutions, which are bad for babies and pressure women to have abortions, describes himself on his Facebook campaign page as “a voice for the children, born and unborn.” It is also odd that not a single “pro-life” organization has spoken out against these arrests.

Kathlyn Jean Lopez, author of The Fictional Post-Roe Prison Rush asserts that “[p]rolife legislators and pro-life leaders do not support the prosecution of women.” According to Marjorie Dannenfelser in One Untrue Thing, the goal of laws designed to protect the unborn is the “protection” of women, “not punishment.” And Father Frank Pavone of Priests for Life has said that the “pro-life movement is not out to punish women.”

Yet, as new mothers in Alabama are hauled off to jail and their babies denied a mother’s care, there has been no objection from any of these so called pro-life organizations or individuals.

If it is true that those who support the re-criminalization of abortion and the rights of fertilized eggs, embryos and fetuses want to protect pregnant women, rather than prosecute them, now would be a good time to join National Advocates for Pregnant Women, the Drug Policy Alliance, the Southern Poverty Law Center, and the 47 health and human rights organizations that are speaking out against the prosecution and imprisonment of women in Alabama.

Lynn Paltrow is executive director of National Advocates for Pregnant Women.
Link to original article from AlterNet

blog comments powered by Disqus

States - Alabama

Alabama Articles

Prev Next Page:

Federal Judge in Don Siegelman Case Arrested, Charged with Abusing Wife in Atlanta Hotel

Federal Judge in Don Siegelman Case Arrested, Charged with Abusing Wife in Atlanta Hotel

The federal judge who oversaw the political prosecution of former Democratic Alabama Gov. Don Siegelman was arrested over the weekend after allegedly beating his wife in a posh hotel room in Atlanta... U.S. District Court Judge Mark Fuller was charged with misdemeanor battery and taken to the Fulton County jail around 2:30 Sunday morning. Fuller, 55, is a judge in the Middle District of Alabama and presided over the 2006 bribery trial of former Alabama Gov. Don Siegelman and HealthSouth CEO Richard Scrushy. Police responded to the Ritz-Carlton Hotel at 181 Peachtree...

Brad Friedman | The Brad Blog 12 Aug 2014 Hits:605 Alabama

Read more

Alabama inmates stage protest over free labor system

Alabama inmates stage protest over free labor system

For the second time this year, prisoners in Alabama are planning a nonviolent demonstration and work stoppage to protest conditions inside the state’s prisons. Melvin Ray, an inmate at the St. Clair correctional facility in Springville and founder of prison-based group Free Alabama Movement (FAM) says this weekend’s strike is an effort to improve education programs and end overcrowding, harsh sentencing, and what he calls “the free labor system” in which prisoners work for little-to-no monetary compensation. In an interview with Salon, Ray said, “There is not even a pretense of doing...

Nick Ramsey | MSNBC 20 Apr 2014 Hits:417 Alabama

Read more

Rep. Terri's Sewell's Press Release on Medicaid/Gov Bentley

Rep. Terri's Sewell's Press Release on Medicaid/Gov Bentley

Alabama's 7th District Congresswoman Terri Sewell just released this press release a few moments ago. We are delighted that she has joined with Progressive Democrats of America, Greater Birmingham Ministries, and the Birmingham Metro Chapter of the NAACP to urge Governor Bentley to accept federal Medicaid funds and has herewith shown her convictions on this issue. From Rep. Sewell... Statement from Congresswoman Terri A. Sewell Urging the State of Alabama to Expand Medicaid under the Affordable Care Act December 10, 2013 “Beginning in January, millions of Americans will begin receiving health coverage under...

Edward Savela 10 Dec 2013 Hits:537 Alabama

Read more

Alabama group rallies for medicaid expansion

Alabama group rallies for medicaid expansion

  BIRMINGHAM, Ala. (WIAT) - Frigid temperatures Saturday afternoon didn't keep a group from rallying in protest of Governor Robert Bentley's decision not to expand the state's Medicaid Programs. For months, Alabama has stood firm behind its decision to opt out of the Medicaid expansion set to go into effect next year as part of the Affordable Care Act. Among the diverse group was recent Samford University graduate Elizabeth Milne. Milne is currently working two jobs, neither provide options for healthcare. She's also a foster child, and cannot get insurance through her parents. "When the...

Tiffany Westry | cbs42 08 Dec 2013 Hits:517 Alabama

Read more

Alabama progressives urge Gov. Bentley to end 'government malpractice,' expand Medicaid in…

Alabama progressives urge Gov. Bentley to end 'government malpractice,' expand Medicaid in Alabama for economic, health reasons (video)

BIRMINGHAM, Alabama - Representatives of Greater Birmingham Ministries, the Birmingham chapter of the NAACP and the Progressive Democrats of America gathered Monday in Birmingham's Kelly Ingram Park to urge Alabama Gov. Robert Bentley to expand Medicaid coverage in Alabama under the Affordable Care Act, known colloquially as Obamacare. "Medicaid expansion is the right thing to do now," Scott Douglas, the executive director of Greater Birmingham Ministries, said. "Now is the right time to do it, and Alabama's working families need it, and that should be reason enough. If the governor refuses...

Madison Underwood | AL.com 28 Oct 2013 Hits:544 Alabama

Read more

Former Alabama Governor Is a Political Prisoner; President Obama, Pardon Him NOW!

Former Alabama Governor Is a Political Prisoner;  President Obama, Pardon Him NOW!

Listen to our show with Dana and Joseph Siegelman Former Alabama Governor Don Siegelman, now in federal prison, is coming up on his one-year anniversary of unjust incarceration. Don is not a criminal. He is an American political prisoner—targeted, prosecuted, and jailed unjustly. We need your help. Please join us in asking President Obama to pardon Don and set him free now! One hundred and thirteen former and current Attorneys General (Republicans and Democrats) signed an amicus brief to the US Supreme Court stating that Don's "crime" was no crime at all. So what...

Mimi Kennedy 30 Aug 2013 Hits:708 Alabama

Read more

The 7 Most Dysfunctional State Parties

The 7 Most Dysfunctional State Parties

In the past two years, one state party chairman was investigated by the local bar association. Elsewhere, an about-to-be-ousted party leader changed the locks at the headquarters. Two more state parties were threatened with eviction. Traditionally, state parties have been the meeting point between the national political organizations and the local ground game. But in recent cycles, many of them have become so dysfunctional that they are now irrelevant — or even worse, detrimental, to the national party’s efforts. The reasons behind their ineptitude vary: Some parties struggle with finances, others with...

Abby Livingston | Roll Call 24 Jul 2013 Hits:804 Alabama

Read more

The Federation of Southern Cooperatives to honor C.T. Vivian

The Federation of Southern Cooperatives to honor C.T. Vivian

On Thursday, August 15, 2013 at the Birmingham Sheraton in Birmingham, Alabama, the Federation of Southern Cooperatives/Land Assistance Fund (Federation) will honor the legendary C.T. Vivian at its Estelle Witherspoon Lifetime Achievement Award Dinner. William Nelson, President of the CHS Foundation, will serve as honorary chair of the event. The Annual Meeting will be held on August 16 & 17 at the Federation's Rural Training and Research Center in Epes, Alabama; however, some events and workshops will also take place in Birmingham on August 15 (please see the agenda for...

Federation of Southern Cooperatives Land Assistance Fund 23 Jul 2013 Hits:719 Alabama

Read more

Hundreds march at 'Justice for Trayvon' rally in downtown Birmingham

Hundreds march at 'Justice for Trayvon' rally in downtown Birmingham

Exactly one week after a Florida jury found George Zimmerman not guilty in the shooting death of Florida teenager Trayvon Martin, hundreds gathered for another march and rally in Birmingham, part of a nationwide effort spearheaded by the Rev. Al Sharpton. More than 500 people marched, chanted and sang this afternoon outside Birmingham City Hall and in Kelly Ingram Park to speak out against Zimmerman's acquittal. Sharpton's National Action Network organized "Justice for Trayvon" rallies in at least 101 cities Saturday, Birmingham's rally among them. Sharpton called for the rallies to be in front...

Kelsey Stein | al.com 21 Jul 2013 Hits:614 Alabama

Read more

State announces plan for free IDs under new photo voter ID law

State announces plan for free IDs under new photo voter ID law

MONTGOMERY, Alabama  --  Voters without photo identification will have two options for getting a free ID from the state before the state's new photo voter ID law kicks in next year, Secretary of State Beth Chapman announced today. Alabama’s new law requiring people to show a government-issued photo ID to vote is scheduled to go into effect with the party primaries in June of 2014. The law -- to get around accusations that it's a modern poll tax to make people buy ID --   also requires that the state  have...

Kim Chandler | AL.com 30 Jun 2013 Hits:612 Alabama

Read more

Supreme Court Guts Voting Rights Act

Supreme Court Guts Voting Rights Act

In case you haven’t heard…   The Robert's Court just dealt a hostile and destructive blow to democracy. The Voting Rights Act of 1965 has stood as perhaps the greatest triumph for democracy in modern times. Prior to the passage of the VRA of 1965, many states routinely, and blatantly discriminated against voting registration of African Americans. As just one example, in Dallas Country Alabama--home to Selma and where the Bloody Sunday march for voting rights began--of 15,000 eligible black voters in 1965, only 338 were registered. Devious methods were employed throughout the South, and some...

Edward Savela | PDA Alabama 25 Jun 2013 Hits:1729 Alabama

Read more

Police set up roadblocks to 'voluntarily' collect DNA, blood samples from innocent America…

Police set up roadblocks to 'voluntarily' collect DNA, blood samples from innocent Americans

(NaturalNews) When a group of uniformed men wearing guns sets up a road block then ask you to "volunteer" a DNA sample and blood sample, it stretches the definition of "volunteer." But that's what happened in Alabama yesterday as off-duty cops in two counties set up DNA collection roadblocks and stopped cars to ask if drivers wanted to "volunteer" DNA swabs and blood samples. It was all part of a study being conducted by the Pacific Institute for Research and Evaluation, which is probably studying what percentage of the sheeple population...

Mike Adams | Natural News.com 12 Jun 2013 Hits:1704 Alabama

Read more

Nuns on the Bus Visit Birmingham

Nuns on the Bus Visit Birmingham

The Nuns on the Bus, led by Sr. Simone, is on a 6,500 mile journey through predominantly Republican states to encourage our Senate to pass immigration reform. Sr. Simone and others gave inspirational talks calling us to action and reminding us that Christian doctrine commands us to welcome strangers. She and the others reminded us that we first discriminated against the Native Americans, the Irish, the Jews, the Catholic immigrants. This is in our history. It is time to extend the welcome mat to the Hispanic community too through responsible...

Edward Savela | PDA Alabama 05 Jun 2013 Hits:629 Alabama

Read more

Nuns on the Bus

Nuns on the Bus

As some of you might know already, Nuns on the Bus will be making a pass through the south in June. Below are the dates in our states: 6/3 - Orlando, FL, 3pm - Daniel Webster - lobby visit 6/4 - Tallahassee, FL, 10 am - Marco Rubio - lobby visit 6/5 - Birmingham, AL - civil rights rally 6/5 - Atlanta, GA - Chambliss - lobby visit To give you some background: Sister Simone, who runs NETWORK (a Catholic social justice lobby in DC), and other nuns will be taking a bus tour along...

Edward Savela 14 May 2013 Hits:704 Alabama

Read more

Labor Council and Plumbers’ Local in Gadsden, Alabama, Endorse HR 676

On April 15, 2013, the Northeast Alabama Labor Council in Gadsden endorsed HR 676, national single payer health care legislation sponsored by Congressman John Conyers. President Garry "Gabby" Frost brought the resolution before the council in response to an appeal from the All Unions Committee for Single Payer Health Care--HR 676 and from Pippa Abston, MD, Ph D, a board member of Physicians for a National Health Program and a Huntsville, Alabama, pediatrician. "Health care is a necessity not a privilege," said President Frost after the adoption of the resolution for HR...

Kay Tillow 22 Apr 2013 Hits:737 Alabama

Read more

Anniversary, significance of King's "Letter from Birmingham Jail" observed on House floor

Anniversary, significance of King's

The 50th anniversary of Martin Luther King's "Letter from Birmingham Jail" was observed with events throughout the city and extended to Washington D.C. where Rep. Terri Sewell marked today by reading an excerpt of the famous treatise. Sewell, D-Birmingham, used her time on the House of Representatives floor to read a portion of the letter. "The letter became one of the most preeminent documents of the civil rights era," Sewell told her colleagues. "Letter from a Birmingham Jail stands as a reminder of how far we have come in our nation in...

Jseoph D. Bryant | AL.com 21 Apr 2013 Hits:912 Alabama

Read more

Alabama gunman kills bus driver, seizes boy

Alabama gunman kills bus driver, seizes boy

MIDLAND CITY, Ala. (AP) — Police SWAT teams and hostage negotiators were locked in a standoff Wednesday with a gunman authorities say intercepted a school bus, killed the driver, snatched a 6-year-old boy and retreated into a bunker at his home. The gunman, identified by neighbors as Jimmy Lee Dykes, a 65-year-old retired truck driver, was known as “the crazy man” of the neighborhood, a paranoid and menacing figure who once beat a dog to death with a lead pipe, threatened to shoot children...

Phillip Rawls | Associated Press 30 Jan 2013 Hits:706 Alabama

Read more

Alabama Abortion Clinic Struggles; Mississippi’s Forges On

Alabama Abortion Clinic Struggles; Mississippi’s Forges On

When Diane Derzis shut the doors of the New Woman All Women Health Care clinic in Birmingham, Ala., last May, she did not expect the clinic to be shut for good. Derzis, known as the “Abortion Queen” by both her opponents and her supporters in the Deep South, was under investigation by the Alabama Department of Public Health after two of her patients were given an improper dosage of medication. Though Derzis self-reported the incident, which resulted in transporting the two women to a hospital via ambulance but no...

by Lauren Barbato | Ms Blog 22 Sep 2012 Hits:1031 Alabama

Read more

Former governor Don Siegelman lobbies for presidential pardon at DNC

Former governor Don Siegelman lobbies for presidential pardon at DNC

The former Alabama governor was perhaps the highest profile victim of Karl Rove's political machine, sentenced to six years for bribery. Now his last hope for freedom is a presidential pardon Don Siegelman, the former governor of Alabama, has a particular reason to be lobbying for Barack Obama's re-election at this week's Democratic national convention. Siegelman is in Charlotte at the pleasure of a federal judge, and is just days away from resuming a six-and-a-half-year prison sentence, following a widely publicised conviction on bribery charges stemming from...

Andrew Gumbel | The Guardian UK 10 Sep 2012 Hits:1454 Alabama

Read more

Alabama immigration law protestors picket on Federal Courthouse steps in Tuscaloosa

Alabama immigration law protestors picket on Federal Courthouse steps in Tuscaloosa

Protestors from Tuscaloosa and as far as California gathered in front of the Federal Courthouse Building on University Boulevard to sound off over the Alabama anti-immigration law on Monday afternoon. The demonstrators included several undocumented Hispanic immigrants, who said so via megaphone on the courthouse steps as they called the Alabama law an injustice to immigrants living in the state. The U.S. 11th Circuit Court of Appeals today ordered a lower court to block enforcement of a section of Alabama's immigration law that required ...

Ben Flanagan | Blog AL.com 21 Aug 2012 Hits:880 Alabama

Read more

FEDERAL COURT STRIKES DOWN KEY PROVISIONS OF ALABAMA’S IMMIGRATION LAW

NEWSFLASH: A federal appeals court struck down key sections of Alabama’s immigration law in a ruling released today, including a provision mandating that school officials check the immigration status of newly enrolled students. And the 11th Circuit ruled that Alabama and Georgia cannot punish people for harboring or transporting an undocumented immigrant. Following the Supreme Court’s ruling that allowed a somewhat narrowed version of Arizona’s “Show-Me-Your-Papers” provision to go into effect, the appeals court letAlabama and Georgia to begin enforcing a law allowing state and local police to investigate the...

Amanda Peterson Beadle | Think Progress 20 Aug 2012 Hits:821 Alabama

Read more

PDA In Your State

PDA Network - Shows This Week

banner-climatechange1019

wr10-20

banner-agitatorradio

BannerPoliticsofFaithAll

Banner-EndingHomelessnessAll

Sign the Petition

Button-DetroitWater

 

Alabama Leadership

 

For support in organizing within your state, contact:

EdSavela      
Edward Savela    

 

State Leadership
Edward Savela

Email us at: field@pdamerica.org

Chapters

Birmingham (forming)
Tuscaloosa (forming)
 
Want to bring progressive change to Alabama? Start a PDA chapter; send us an email and we'll get you started.

 Button-Donate-Blue

ButtonJoinPDAAlabama

PDA Issues

PDA is organized around several core issues. These issues include:

Each team hosts a monthly conference call. Calls feature legislators, staffers and other policy experts. On these calls we determine PDA legislation to support as well as actions and future events.

AL Legislators with ALEC Ties

House of Representatives

Senate

  • Sen. Steve French (R-15)[20]
  • Sen. Cam Ward (R-14)[21]
  • Sen. Jabo Waggoner (R-16)[22]
Information from Sourcewatch:

PR Rank