DC Mississippi in DC: GOP Pushes Zygote Personhood Bills

People Demanding Action Radio Network

Banner

As the Southern state votes on an extreme anti-abortion (and anti-contraception) constitutional amendment, congressional Republicans want to take the plan national.

On Tuesday, voters in Mississippi will head to the polls to vote on an amendment to the state Constitution that would designate inseminated human eggs as legal persons from the "moment of fertilization." This would set up a challenge to Roe v. Wade and could lead to outlawing many forms of birth control. In Mississippi, the proposed amendment has created a political firestorm that's being closely watched by both sides of the national abortion debate. But this fight is not merely a Mississippi matter: In Washington, House and Senate Republicans are pushing legislation that would do the exact same thing on the federal level.

The Mississippi amendment alters the state's Constitution so that "the term 'person' or 'persons' shall include every human being from the moment of fertilization, cloning, or the functional equivalent thereof." Nearly identical language appears in three bills that have been endorsed by scores of Republicans in Congress, including top House committee chairmen Spencer Bachus (R-Ala.) and Paul Ryan (R-Wis.) and presidential candidate Michele Bachmann (R-Minn.).

Like the Mississippi measure, these bills represent attempts to extend the rights of legal personhood—including equal protection under the law—to a zygote, the single cell formed when a human sperm fuses with an egg. The national measures are "designed to achieve the same end" as the Mississippi effort, says Sara Rosenbaum, a health law expert and professor at George Washington University who frequently testifies before Congress on reproductive rights issues. "The aim of the bills is to reclassify or to overturn…the fundamental constitutional fact on which Roe v. Wade rests," she adds. Opponents of abortion rights agree with Rosenbaum's analysis: The National Pro-Life Alliance, a group that backs all three bills, calls them "a frontal assault on Roe v. Wade" and sees them as a way of "legislatively overturning" the Supreme Court decision.

If the bills become law and zygotes are afforded the protection of legal personhood, abortion would be legally equivalent to murder, as would almost anything that interfered with the zygote's development. That could include the morning-after pill, which primarily works by preventing fertilization but which anti-abortion activists insist prevents fertilized eggs from implanting in the uterus. (Many scientists disagree.) Intrauterine devices (IUDs), which can prevent implantation, would also be affected by the laws.

"It's not even abortion, it's not even pregnancy—that's how far back this reaches," says Donna Crane, the policy director for NARAL Pro-Choice America. "It's possibly the most extreme position you can take on this issue and far to the right of where most right-to-life individuals are."

Like the Mississippi amendment, none of the personhood bills being considered in Congress contain any exemptions for victims of rape or incest.

The fallout could extend beyond abortion and contraception. In Mississippi, some critics have questioned whether the passage of the amendment could affect laws unrelated to reproductive rights, such as those that regulate how many "people" can be on a bus or in a school gymnasium at a time. (Mother Jones' Kate Sheppard has more on other "personhood" bills being pushed in states around the country.)

Sixty-three House Republicans, or over a quarter of the GOP conference, are cosponsors of HR 212, Rep. Paul Broun's (R-Ga.) "Sanctity of Human Life Act," which includes language that directly parallels that of the Mississippi personhood amendment. That bill declares that "the life of each human being begins with fertilization, cloning, or its functional equivalent…at which time every human being shall have all the legal and constitutional attributes and privileges of personhood." Five committee chairmen, including budget wunderkind Ryan, support the bill. "There is no greater protection that we as a government can give to protect human beings all the way from the time of fertilization until they have natural deaths," Broun says.

Rep. Duncan Hunter's (R-Calif.) HR 374, an ever-so-slightly tweaked version that includes a clause that says it does not "require" (although it does allow) "the prosecution of any woman for the death of her unborn child," has even more cosponsors—91, including Bachmann (R-Minn.). Nearly 40 percent of House Republicans back this bill, which, like HR 212 and the Mississippi amendment, has language saying that "human persons" exist from "the moment of fertilization" or from any "other moment at which an individual member of the human species comes into being."

Link to original article from Mother Jones

In the Senate, Roger Wicker (R-Miss.) has introduced S 91, a companion bill to HR 374. Wicker has said he hopes his bill will "settle this important life issue once and for all." More than a quarter of Senate Republicans back the proposal.

Polls show the Mississippi personhood bill stands a good chance of passing. "These are the kind of measures, whether state or federal, that would end up at the Supreme Court eventually," Rosenbaum says. "I assume that's the next step."

Nick Baumann covers national politics and civil liberties issues for Mother Jones' DC Bureau. For more of his stories, click here. You can also follow him on Twitter and Facebook. Email tips and insights to nbaumann [at] motherjones [dot] com. Get Nick Baumann's RSS feed.


blog comments powered by Disqus

States - DC

DC News

Prev Next Page:

Obama on D.C. statehood: ‘I’m for it’

Obama on D.C. statehood: ‘I’m for it’

With fewer than a dozen words Monday, President Barack Obama made his most definitive statement to date in favor of District statehood, delighting both loyal supporters and longtime advocates who have questioned his commitment to D.C. voting rights. During a town hall-style event at a public school in Northwest Washington, Obama was asked about his opinion on statehood — something that has been the ultimate but elusive goal of voting-rights activists for four decades. “I’m in D.C., so I’m for it,” Obama said to laughter and applause, according to a White House...

Mike DeBonis | The Washington Post 21 Jul 2014 Hits:347 DC

Read more

New Bill to Tax and Legalize Marijuana in D.C. Could Solve Budget Deficit

New Bill to Tax and Legalize Marijuana in D.C. Could Solve Budget Deficit

Legalizing weed may be the answer to Congress's national budget crisis as activists push for a system where weed is taxed. As U.S. lawmakers look for ways to balance the national budget, a new bill formally introduced to the D.C. council this week may provide the answer as a major source of tax revenue. The bill aims to legalize possession of marijuana for adults over 21, regulate sale and licensing and tax the transactions in order to help generate much-needed tax revenue in the nation's capital. Initiated by Councilman David Grosso, the bill...

Jodie Gummow | AlterNet 23 Sep 2013 Hits:664 DC

Read more

Teachers Signal 'War Cry' Against Corporate Reform

Teachers Signal 'War Cry' Against Corporate Reform

Teachers and education activists from near and far descended on the Department of Education in Washington D.C. this weekend to announce their "war cry" against the corporate-based school reform movement and its stranglehold on public education. Protesters at the second annual Occupy the Department of Education, which took place from April 4-7, are trying to draw attention to the rampant privatization of public education which has benefited greatly from President Obama's Race to the Top initiative, as well as the rash of public school closures—most notably in Chicago, Washington D.C. and...

Lauren McCauley | Common Dreams 07 Apr 2013 Hits:774 DC

Read more

'American Autumn,' Documentary About Occupy Movement, Screens At Busboys And Poets

'American Autumn,' Documentary About Occupy Movement, Screens At Busboys And Poets

Remember when McPherson Square was full of tents? Almost a year after the Occupy movement first came to town -- and some seven months since Occupy DC's controversial, reportedly rat-infested encampment came down -- you can relive the whole maddening and compelling experience while eating vegan nachos. If you've missed watching people get arrested while chanting about the need for campaign-finance reform, you'll want to check out "American Autumn: an Occudoc," a documentary about the Occupy movement's early days that will be screening from 7-10 p.m. at Busboys and...

Arin Greenwood | Huffington Post 21 Aug 2012 Hits:742 DC

Read more

Multitudes Stand their Ground in DC

Multitudes Stand their Ground in DC

MrLowe, of Glenn Dale, Maryland, attended and participated in a protest held at Freedom Plaza in Washington, D.C. 'The photo depicts six young African American women, each wearing matching red hoodies with a portrait of Trayvon Martin on the back. Their backs are turned toward the camera with their heads bowed and their fists raised in the air - an iconic gesture made immortal during the civil rights era of the 1960s and intimately familiar to African Americans every since,' he says. He...

Mr. Lowe | CNN Justice Report 26 Mar 2012 Hits:564 DC

Read more

George Clooney arrested during protest in Washington, D.C.

George Clooney arrested during protest in Washington, D.C.

Actor George Clooney has been arrested in Washington during a protest at the Sudanese Embassy, just two days after dining with the president at a White House state dinner and testifying before Congress about a mounting humanitarian crisis in the African country. Also arrested were two Democratic members of Congress – Massachusetts Rep. Jim McGovern and Virginia Rep. Jim Moran – Clooney’s father, Nick, NAACP president Ben Jealous and Rabbi Steve Gutow, president of the Jewish Council for Public Affairs. The men were arrested by the Secret Service, which protects the...

Ian Duncan | LA Times 16 Mar 2012 Hits:809 DC

Read more

D.C. Judge Says Credibility of Police Sworn Statements "Smashed to Smithereens"

D.C. Judge Says Credibility of Police Sworn Statements

A Superior Court Judge in the District of Columbia slammed the D.C. Metropolitan Police Department (MPD) for submitting “transparently false” affidavits in an unsuccessful effort to defeat a lawsuit brought by the Partnership for Civil Justice Fund (PCJF) that demands that the MPD disclose its orders and policies. Judge Judith N. Macaluso ruled in favor of the PCJF lawsuit forcing the MPD to release documents that it has spent years concealing and refusing to disclose. The PCJF's litigation has resulted in the largest and...

Partnership for Civil Justice 14 Mar 2012 Hits:865 DC

Read more

The two Americas clash at CPAC

The two Americas clash at CPAC

The two Americas came face to face briefly Friday afternoon at the Conservative Political Action Conference in Washington, D.C. While several thousand conservatives thronged the Wardman Park Marriott Hotel, several hundred progressive unionists marched up to the hotel’s entrance, banging drums, carrying signs like “CPAC: Conservatives Pleasing America’s Corporations” and chanting “We are the 99 percent.” As they were turned back by police and hotel security, conference participants watched, often with disdain. “Get a job,” shouted one conservative. “I’ve got a job,” one...

Jefferson Morley | Salon.com 11 Feb 2012 Hits:620 DC

Read more

In Washington, Black Clergy Establishes Occupy the Dream

In Washington, Black Clergy Establishes Occupy the Dream

Invoking the ministry of Jesus and the legacy of Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. as advocates for the poorest and most vulnerable of their societies, prominent African-American clergy members Wednesday joined the Occupy Wall St. movement, announcing a day of action in Washington D.C. on Jan. 16, the King holiday. Dubbed “Occupy the Dream,” the group is led by Dr. Benjamin Chavis and Dr. Jamal Bryant of Empowerment Temple in Baltimore, Maryland. Chavis said that if Dr. King were alive today he would have been a part of...

Darren Sands | Loop 21 20 Dec 2011 Hits:859 DC

Read more

Mississippi in DC: GOP Pushes Zygote Personhood Bills

Mississippi in DC: GOP Pushes Zygote Personhood Bills

As the Southern state votes on an extreme anti-abortion (and anti-contraception) constitutional amendment, congressional Republicans want to take the plan national. On Tuesday, voters in Mississippi will head to the polls to vote on an amendment to the state Constitution that would designate inseminated human eggs as legal persons from the "moment of fertilization." This would set up a challenge to Roe v. Wade and could lead to outlawing many forms of birth control. In Mississippi, the proposed amendment has created a political firestorm that's being closely...

Nick Baumann | Mother Jones 08 Nov 2011 Hits:795 DC

Read more

Thousands of Protesters Encircle White House, Close in on Tar Sands Industry

Thousands of Protesters Encircle White House, Close in on Tar Sands Industry

“We don’t know how many people it takes to encircle the White House, but we’re about to find out,” Bill McKibben told a crowd of over 12,000 gathered in Lafayette Square on Sunday afternoon. Such a prospect would have been hard to imagine eleven weeks earlier, when McKibben was standing in the same park with no more than a hundred people listening. It was the first day of what would become a two-week long campaign of mass civil disobedience targeting the planned construction...

Bryan Farrell | Sourced from Waging Nonviolence 07 Nov 2011 Hits:478 DC

Read more

Koch Group Gathering Disrupted by Occupy DC Protesters; Things Get Tense as Activists Surr…

Koch Group Gathering Disrupted by Occupy DC Protesters; Things Get Tense as Activists Surround Building

Time was when David Koch could bring his Americans for Prosperity Foundation convention to our nation's capital, and conventioneers could feel pretty secure in the notion that Washington, D.C., was theirs for the taking. No longer. The triumphant glow of hagiography that usually marks the convention's annual Ronald Reagan tribute dinner tonight gave way to the heat of confrontation with the Occupy D.C. movement. Apparently, the AFP Foundation was prepared for shenanigans, as there seemed to be a readily available cadre of Metropolitan...

Adele M. Stan | AlterNet 05 Nov 2011 Hits:1181 DC

Read more

Sallie Mae Locks Out Student Protestors

Sallie Mae Locks Out Student Protestors

“The demonstrators, who had planned to voice their grievances in the lobby of the building, began chanting “if we had money, they’d let us in!”” Yesterday afternoon, a group of about seventy-five students mobilized at the OccupyDC camp at McPherson Square to raise the issue of crushing student debt. The average student, facing grim job prospects in the current economy, is graduating with at least $24,000 of debt. The students and recent graduates then marched several blocks through DC to the lobbying headquarters of student loan giant Sallie...

Lee Fang | ThinkProgress 28 Oct 2011 Hits:517 DC

Read more

Mic Check! Freedom Plaza Day 2

Mic Check! Freedom Plaza Day 2

Friday was a good day for waking up in Freedom Plaza and for occupying the headquarters of the drone manufacturers.  Fast forward to minute 44 on this video http://www.ustream.tv/recorded/17729809 Their intelligence about which way we were coming from was no better at keeping us out of their building than the CIA's intelligence is at making sure the "right" people are murdered with the drones. Friday was a good day for marching to the Martin Luther King Jr. memorial and talking about his opposition to...

David Swanson | War Is A Crime 08 Oct 2011 Hits:431 DC

Read more

Demonstrators Protest Wars, Wall Street in Nation's Capitol

Demonstrators Protest Wars, Wall Street in Nation's Capitol

Civil rights activist and comedian Dick Gregory spoke at the rally, saying the demonstrators reminded him of the young anti-war protesters in the late 1960s, who were emboldened by the civil rights protests. A sun-soaked noon rally within blocks of the White House brought out hundreds of protesters Thursday to mark the 10th anniversary of the Afghanistan War. On Freedom Square, sign-carrying demonstrators banged drums, sang and cheered a series of fiery speeches by anti-war activists, who decried the federal government's continued funding of the Afghan and Iraqi wars while calling for...

Tonu Pugh | McClatchy 07 Oct 2011 Hits:426 DC

Read more

PDA In Your State

PDA Network - Shows This Week

banner-climatechange1019

wr10-20

banner-agitatorradio

BannerPoliticsofFaithAll

Banner-EndingHomelessnessAll

Sign the Petition

Button-DetroitWater

 

PDA Issues

PDA is organized around several core issues. These issues include:

Each team hosts a monthly conference call. Calls feature legislators, staffers and other policy experts. On these calls we determine PDA legislation to support as well as actions and future events.

PR Rank