Montana 22 states, DC back Montana in Supreme Court corporate spending fight

MT-SupremeCourt2HELENA, Mont. — Twenty-two states and the District of Columbia are backing Montana in its fight to prevent the U.S. Supreme Court’s 2010 Citizens United decision from being used to strike down state laws restricting corporate campaign spending.

The states led by New York are asking the high court to preserve Montana’s state-level regulations on corporate political expenditures, according to a copy of a brief written by New York’s attorney general’s office and obtained by The Associated Press. The brief will be publicly released Monday.

The Supreme Court is being asked to reverse a state court’s decision to uphold the Montana law. Virginia-based American Tradition Partnership is asking the nation’s high court to rule without a hearing because the group says the state law conflicts directly with the Citizens United decision that removed the federal ban on corporate campaign spending.

The Supreme Court has blocked the Montana law until it can look at the case.

The Montana case has prompted critics to hope the court will reverse itself on the controversial Citizens United ruling. The 22 states and D.C. say the Montana law is sharply different from the federal issues in the Citizens United case, so the ruling shouldn’t apply to Montana’s or other state laws regulating corporate campaign spending.

But the states also said they would support a Supreme Court decision to reconsider portions of the Citizens United ruling either in a future case or in the Montana case, if the justices decide to take it on.

Legal observers say don’t count on the Supreme Court reconsidering its decision.

“It is highly unlikely that the Court would reverse its decision in Citizens United,” said law professor Richard L. Hasen of the University of California-Irvine.

At best, the court would listen to arguments and might agree a clarification is needed to allow the Montana law to stand. But even that is a long shot, Hasen said.

Montana Attorney General Steve Bullock argues that political corruption in the Copper King era led to the state ban on corporate campaign spending. A clarification of Citizens United is needed to make clear that states can block certain political spending in the interest of limiting corruption, he said.

American Tradition Partnership argues that the state bans unfairly restrict the ability of corporations to engage in the political process that also affects them.

Bullock wrote in a brief to be released Monday that the state does not “ban” corporate political speech, rather, it regulates that speech by requiring the formation of political action committees.

The Democrat, who is running for governor, said the upstart political corporations hoping to take advantage of unfettered spending are merely “an anonymous conduit of unaccountable campaign spending.”

Montana and the other states are asking the court to either let the Montana Supreme Court decision stand or to hold a full hearing. They argue laws like the one in Montana that bans political spending straight from corporate treasuries are needed to prevent corruption.

The other states, many with their own type of restrictions hanging in the balance, argue local restrictions are far different than the federal ban the court decided unconstitutionally restricted free speech. Further, state elections are at much greater risk than federal elections of being dominated by corporate money, requiring tailored regulation, the states’ court filing says.

“The federal law struck down in Citizens United applied only to elections for President and U.S. Congress,” New York Attorney General Eric Schneiderman wrote on behalf of the states. “By contrast, Montana’s law applies to a wide range of state and local offices, including judgeships and law enforcement positions such as sheriff and county prosecutor.”

 The joining states, unlike Montana, ask the court to go further and reconsider core findings in Citizens United. They argue, for instance, it was wrong for the court to say unlimited independent expenditures rarely cause corruption or the appearance of corruption.

And other critics of the Citizens United decision who believe the court was wrong to grant corporations constitutional rights, have intervened and asked the court to reverse itself.

“There is a growing bipartisan consensus that Citizens United needs to be overturned, and Montana is leading the way,” said Peter Schurman, spokesman for a group called Free Speech For People. “The Supreme Court has an opportunity to revisit Citizens United here. That is important because there is evidence everywhere that unlimited spending in our elections creates both corruption and the appearance for corruption.”

On Friday, Montana’s case was given a boost when U.S. Sens. John McCain, R-Ariz., and Sheldon Whitehouse, D-R.I., signed on in support. The senators argue evidence following the Citizens United decision, where millions in unregulated money has poured into presidential elections, shows that large independent expenditures can lead to corruption.

The states who filed the brief in support of Montana are New York, Arkansas, California, Connecticut, Delaware, Hawaii, Idaho, Illinois, Iowa, Kentucky, Maryland, Massachusetts, Minnesota, Mississippi, Nevada, New Mexico, North Carolina, Rhode Island, Utah, Vermont, Washington, West Virginia and the District of Columbia.

___

Associated Press writer Mark Sherman in Washington contributed to this report.

Link to original article from The Washington Post


blog comments powered by Disqus

States - Montana

Montana News

Prev Next Page:

Baucus to retire rather than seek re-election in 2014, strategists say

Baucus to retire rather than seek re-election in 2014, strategists say

Senate Finance Committee Chairman Max Baucus (D-Mont.) is retiring rather than seek re-election in 2014, according to two senior Democratic strategists familiar with his plans. First elected in 1978, Baucus has been the top Democrat on the powerful committee since 2001. The likely Democratic candidate to succeed him would be former governor Brian Schweitzer, sources said. First elected in 1978, Baucus has been the top Democrat on the powerful tax-writing committee for more than a dozen years. At times infuriating his Democratic colleagues, he worked with Republicans to co-write the Bush-era tax...

Paul Kane | Washington Post 23 Apr 2013 Hits:1554 Montana

Read more

Tax Lobby Builds Ties to Chairman of Finance Panel

Tax Lobby Builds Ties to Chairman of Finance Panel

Restaurant chains like McDonald’s want to keep their lucrative tax credit for hiring veterans. Altria, the tobacco giant, wants to cut the corporate tax rate. And Sapphire Energy, a small alternative energy company, is determined to protect a tax incentive it believes could turn algae into a popular motor fuel. To make their case as Congress prepares to debate a rewrite of the nation’s tax code, this diverse set of businesses has at least one strategy in common: they have retained firms that employ lobbyists who are former aides to Max...

Eric Lipton | The New York Times 14 Apr 2013 Hits:550 Montana

Read more

Schweitzer vs. Baucus? Montana ex-governor posts poll

Schweitzer vs. Baucus? Montana ex-governor posts poll

Without comment, former Montana governor Brian Schweitzer has posted a poll on his Facebook page that suggests he would beat Sen. Max Baucus in a 2014 Democratic primary. The survey, from the Democratic firm Public Policy Polling, finds that Schweitzer would be a stronger candidate in both the Senate primary and a general election. “This was a really odd thing to post,” one commenter says. “I’m all for Schweitzer, but for the social media team to post polling data showing the former governor leading primary polls against another Democrat is just strange.” Another responds,...

Rachel Wiener | Washington Post 20 Feb 2013 Hits:603 Montana

Read more

In Montana, Dark Money Helped Democrats Hold a Key Senate Seat

In Montana, Dark Money Helped Democrats Hold a Key Senate Seat

Democratic Sen. Jon Tester, left, Libertarian Dan Cox, center, and Republican Rep. Denny Rehberg participate in a senate debate at Flathead Valley Community College in Kalispell, Mont., on Oct. 14, 2012. With control of the Senate at stake, liberals hit the streets and bought ads for libertarian candidate Cox, who likely siphoned crucial votes away from Republican challenger Rehberg. (Flathead Beacon, Lido Vizzutti/AP Photo) The 2012 U.S. Senate contest reveals why secret outside money became the biggest political trend of 2012. In the waning days of...

Kim Barker | Pro Publica 28 Dec 2012 Hits:602 Montana

Read more

Supreme Court's Plutocratic Political Hacks Rule Against the People in Montana

Supreme Court's Plutocratic Political Hacks Rule Against the People in Montana

The Citizens United 5: Clarence Thomas, Anthony Kennedy, John Roberts, Antonin Scalia and Sam Alito "Two wrongs don't make a right," as my old Texas momma used to instruct my brothers and me. But apparently, five of the justices on our Supreme Court didn't have mommas with such ethical sensibilities — or perhaps they're just ignoring their mommas' wisdom now in order to impose their extremist political agenda on you and me. That agenda became startlingly clear in 2010, when the black-robed cabal of Clarence Thomas, Anthony...

Jim Hightower | 05 Jul 2012 Hits:717 Montana

Read more

Birthers Erect ‘Obama Outhouse’ At Montana GOP Convention

Birthers Erect ‘Obama Outhouse’ At Montana GOP Convention

A shotgun, an outhouse, and a birth certificate stamped “bullshit” all made appearances at Montana’s GOP convention over the weekend. At Saturday’s convention in Missoula, Montana, a few convention-goers set up outside with an outhouse labeled “Obama’s Presidential Library.” But that wasn’t the most outrageous part. According to the Missoulian, the outhouse was also decorated in sexism, birtherism, and implicit threats: The outhouse was painted to look as though it had been riddled by bullets. Inside, a fake birth certificate for Barack Hussein Obama made reference to the disproven controversy over...

Annie-Rose Strasser | Think Progress 18 Jun 2012 Hits:690 Montana

Read more

Judge indicates Montana campaign law on judicial races may fall

Judge indicates Montana campaign law on judicial races may fall

HELENA — A federal judge Friday indicated he may strike down a long-standing Montana campaign law that bans political parties from spending money on or endorsing nonpartisan judicial candidates. But U.S. District Judge Charles Lovell of Helena declined to suspend the law before Montana’s primary election next Tuesday, saying the issue needs a wider hearing before taking such action. “I think this is a very serious issue and the plaintiffs have a sound and authoritative basis for their position,” Lovell said. “But I do agree...

Mike Dennison | Gazette State Bureau 04 Jun 2012 Hits:649 Montana

Read more

22 states, DC back Montana in Supreme Court corporate spending fight

22 states, DC back Montana in Supreme Court corporate spending fight

HELENA, Mont. — Twenty-two states and the District of Columbia are backing Montana in its fight to prevent the U.S. Supreme Court’s 2010 Citizens United decision from being used to strike down state laws restricting corporate campaign spending. The states led by New York are asking the high court to preserve Montana’s state-level regulations on corporate political expenditures, according to a copy of a brief written by New York’s attorney general’s office and obtained by The Associated Press. The brief will be publicly released...

Associated Press | The Washington Post 23 May 2012 Hits:1037 Montana

Read more

Rally at Capitol Saturday champions women’s cause

Rally at Capitol Saturday champions women’s cause

Dylan Brown Independent Record - Margarita McLarty holds up a sign at the Unite Against the War on Women rally in front of the Capitol building Saturday. About 200 people showed up at the event. About 200 men, women and children from throughout Montana gathered in front of the Capitol building in Helena Saturday to voice their outrage at efforts around the county and within the state that they believe are anti-women measures. “Legislation is being introduced in states that is a full-blown effort to strip...

Eve Byron | Helena Independent Record 29 Apr 2012 Hits:606 Montana

Read more

Democratic Rep. Franke Wilmer officially files for U.S. House seat

Democratic Rep. Franke Wilmer officially files for U.S. House seat

HELENA - Democratic state Rep. Franke Wilmer of Bozeman filed for the U.S. House seat Wednesday with a commitment to fight for giving people a fair chance to achieve the American dream. Wilmer, 61, is a three-term legislator, a political science professor at Montana State University and one of seven candidates seeking the Democratic primary nomination for the open U.S. House seat. "I think we've got a lot of work to do," she said. "I think we need someone in Congress who understands that we're all in this together. We have to...

Charles S. Johnson | Missoula State Bureau 31 Mar 2012 Hits:816 Montana

Read more

Three congressional challengers very worth supporting

Three congressional challengers very worth supporting

Norman Solomon, Franke Wilmer and Cecil Bothwell For those devoted to watching the 2012 election, the presidential horse race eats up the vast bulk of attention (which is why I’m not one of those devoted to watching it), but throughout the year there are also party primaries for Congressional seats. Most Congressional contests are boring and largely inconsequential; the vast bulk features certain victory by unnotable incumbents or open-seat races between Party-approved, script-reading, poll-driven, cookie-cutter challengers. But there are a few new candidates for...

Glenn Greenwald | Salon.com 31 Mar 2012 Hits:992 Montana

Read more

Saying No to Corruption: Why Montana Is Fighting The U.S. Supreme Court

Saying No to Corruption: Why Montana Is Fighting The U.S. Supreme Court

"Campaigns were conducted by simply the opening of a barrel, and sowing the state from one end to the other with corporation money—the largest barrel winning in the end. This extravagant campaigning prevented the election of any but the wealthy or those supported by special interests." --from the Terry (Montana) Tribune, February 1910. There’s no end to the colorful stories of corporate corruption in Montana during the years preceding passage of our now-endangered Corrupt Practices Act, which banned direct corporate electioneering. Montana has the dubious honor of...

Jeff Milchen | AlterNet 11 Mar 2012 Hits:744 Montana

Read more

Supreme Court blocks Montana campaign finance ruling

Supreme Court blocks Montana campaign finance ruling

The U.S. Supreme Court has blocked a Montana Supeme Court ruling upholding the constitutionality of that state's ban on independent expenditures by corporations in state and local political campaigns. In a unanimous order issued late Friday afternoon (and posted here), the high court's justices stayed the Montana court's decision. The move clears the way for independent expenditures in Montana, at least until the U.S. Supreme Court takes final action in the case. Critics of the Montana court's 7-2 decision issued Dec. 30 said it flew directly in...

Josh Gerstein | Politico 19 Feb 2012 Hits:1077 Montana

Read more

Montana Ban On Corporate Campaigning Heading To U.S. Supreme Court

Montana Ban On Corporate Campaigning Heading To U.S. Supreme Court

A late 2011 decision by Montana's state Supreme Court upholding its century-old ban on corporate campaign spending is heading to the U.S. Supreme Court, as activist Republican lawyers have filed papers asking the high court to stay--or freeze--that ban in the upcoming 2012 election season, arguing that the Montana Supreme Court cannot ignore the U.S. Supreme Court's controversial Citizens United ruling. The brief filed by James Bopp, who heads a political law firm that has targeted state and federal laws limiting campaign spending...

Steven Rosenfeld | Sourced from AlterNet 10 Feb 2012 Hits:699 Montana

Read more

Why I Occupy

Why I Occupy

I’m participating in the Occupy Wall Street movement as part of Occupy Helena because it was Wall Street and corporate millionaires and their greed that led to the financial meltdown of September 2008 that has left our nation with 24-25 million people still unemployed or underemployed, with millions of Americans losing not only their jobs but also their homes and savings. While the Wall Street corporate 1% are experiencing record profits and bonuses, the number of people living in poverty and hunger in the United States is at levels not seen...

Frank Kromkowski | Occupy Helena 26 Jan 2012 Hits:534 Montana

Read more

PDA In Your State

PDA Radio - Upcoming Show

Listen "Live" Saturday 7/12 @ 3pm EST
The Chicano Chronicles
with Jacque DelRio
jacque

Genocide in Detroit
Guests Monica Patrick Lewis and
Ben Zion Ptashnik

Sign the Petition

Button-DetroitWater

 

PDA Issues

PDA is organized around several core issues. These issues include:

Each team hosts a monthly conference call. Calls feature legislators, staffers and other policy experts. On these calls we determine PDA legislation to support as well as actions and future events.

Montana Leadership

For support in organizing within your state, contact:

       
     

 

State Leadership
Frank Kromkowski

Email us at: montana@pdamerica.org

Chapters

Want to bring progressive change to Montana? Start a PDA chapter; send us an email and we'll get you started.

BlueDonate2

 

MT Legislators with ALEC Ties

House of Representatives

Senate

Information from Sourcewatch:

PR Rank