Pennsylvania Pennsylvania is Just the Latest Ruling Upholding Voter ID Law

Voting4 On Wednesday, in a closely watched case, a state judge in Pennsylvania declined to block the state’s controversial voter ID law from taking effect. If the ruling is upheld on appeal, registered voters in the state will be required to show acceptable photo ID during the general election in November.

There’s been a lot of attention on this lawsuit, given the closeness of the election and greater focus on voter ID laws, which critics say could disenfranchise voters who are likely to lack photo ID, often the poor, elderly, and minorities. (To catch up on this issue, check out our guide on everything you need to know about voter ID laws.)

Yesterday’s ruling has generated plenty of criticism and concern. But it’s far from the first time a judge has ruled on voter ID laws, a number of times in favor of them. Indeed, the U.S. Supreme Court has upheld Indiana’s strict voter ID law, saying in 2008 that it’s constitutional.

Lawsuits have continued to crop up challenging the laws, mostly on the grounds that they violate state constitutions. Meanwhile, Republican-led state legislatures are continuing to pass the laws.

To get a real sense of where things may be going, it’s helpful to look at the past. Here’s a rundown of state court decisions on voter ID laws:

Three rulings in favor of voter ID laws

  • In July 2007, in an advisory opinion sought by the state House of Representatives, the Michigan Supreme Court concluded that the state’s photo ID requirement was a “reasonable, nondiscriminatory restriction designed to preserve the purity of elections and to prevent abuses of the electoral franchise.” The court said there was no need for the legislature to prove voter fraud existed before taking “prophylactic action.” As part of the ruling, the court said the photo ID restrictions were not overly harsh. The opinion included two dissents.
  • In June 2010, the Indiana Supreme Court sided with a lower court judge in dismissing a motion to toss out the state’s voter ID law. The court ruled that the law is a valid “election regulation” and held the burdens were not “sufficiently unreasonable.” In addition, the court frequently referenced the 2008 U.S. Supreme Court decision, which upheld Indiana’s voter ID law on federal constitutional grounds. The state Supreme Court’s decision included one dissent.
  • In March 2011, the Georgia Supreme Court affirmed a lower court’s ruling upholding the state’s voter ID law. It found the state’s photo ID requirement was a “minimal, reasonable, and nondiscriminatory restriction” and repeatedly cited the U.S. Supreme Court decision as persuasive authority. It also rejected the argument that Georgia’s Constitution afforded greater voting protections than the federal Constitution, arguing it was “coextensive” and that “we apply them as one.” There was one dissent.

Rulings against voter ID laws

  • In October 2006, the Missouri Supreme Court upheld a lower court’s decision striking down the state’s voter ID law for violating the state constitution. The court ruled that there was no compelling state interest to justify the burdens posed by the law. It pointed to the lack of any reported instances of voter impersonation fraud in the state and to the fact that the law was not tailored to prevent other types of voter fraud aside from impersonation. There was one dissenting vote.

    Missouri passed a photo ID law again in 2011, but it was vetoed by Democratic Gov. Jay Nixon. Earlier this year, a ballot proposal to amend the state Constitution for a photo ID requirement was rejected by a state judge and not revised before the legislature recessed.

  • In March 2012, the first of two state judges in Wisconsin to rule on the law barred enforcement of the law. The judge warned of possible disenfranchisement of voters that could include “those struggling souls who, unlike the vast majority of Wisconsin voters, for whatever reason will lack the financial, physical, mental, or emotional resources” to comply with the law.

    In July, a separate state judge similarly blocked the law. The judge cited the time and cost of obtaining photo ID and the strong voting protections extended by the Wisconsin Constitution.

    Although the Wisconsin Attorney General filed an appeal of these two decisions to the state Supreme Court, it’s not likely the appeals will be considered before the November election.

  • In Wednesday’s ruling out of Pennsylvania, Commonwealth Court Judge Robert Simpson referenced many of these past court rulings, particularly the ones that upheld voter ID laws. He also stressed the need for deference to the Pennsylvania legislature. Criticism of Pennsylvania’s law had intensified after the Republican majority leader of the state’s House had been quoted saying the voter ID law would benefit Republicans. Although the judge called the remark “disturbing,” he wrote that it didn’t change his reasoning.

    Pennsylvania’s photo ID requirement, the judge concluded, “is a reasonable, non-discriminatory, non-severe burden when viewed in the broader context of the widespread use of photo ID in daily life.”

    That doesn’t end things for Pennsylvania. The Justice Department has launched its own investigation into some states’ voter ID laws, including Pennsylvania’s.

    Link to original article from ProPublica


blog comments powered by Disqus

States - Pennsylvania

Pennsylvania Articles

Prev Next Page:

Protesters Order Fitzpatrick to Help End Shutdown

Protesters Order Fitzpatrick to Help End Shutdown

Bucks County activists hung a cease and desist order outside Congressman Mike Fitzpatrick's Langhorne office. In the hours leading up to a rally outside Congressman Mike Fitzpatrick's Langhorne office, it appeared that a deal was close to tend the 15-day shutdown of the federal government. It would have been good news for the protesters that want to see the thousands of federal employees back to work and earning paychecks, even if it stole their thunder a bit. "We would have held the protest anyway," said Robin Stelly of Keystone Progress, one of the...

James Boyle| Levittown Patch 16 Oct 2013 Hits:408 Pennsylvania

Read more

Harrisburg group to target GOP over government shutdown

A liberal group based in Harrisburg will fan out across the state and into the Philadelphia suburbs Tuesday to try to put pressure on Republicans in Congress toward ending the federal government shutdown. Michael Morrill, executive director of Keystone Progress, said hundreds of people will place "cease and desist" posters outside the district offices of House Republicans, placing the blame on them. The National Republican Congressional Committee has called the protest a partisan stunt that ignores efforts by Pennsylvania's GOP House members to end the impasse. While Keystone Progress prepared for the...

Ben Finley | Philadelphia Inquirer 16 Oct 2013 Hits:366 Pennsylvania

Read more

Perry's Adams office gets 'cease and desist' order

Perry's Adams office gets 'cease and desist' order

Sometimes it's the thought that counts. A "cease and desist" order Roger Lund delivered to the Gettysburg office of Rep. Scott Perry, R-York County, doesn't carry any legal weight, but Lund said the message behind the order is the whole point. Lund and a group of about 80 Adams County residents delivered the letter around 11:30 Tuesday morning, about two days before the nation was set to default on its debts. There's a national crisis that, according to Lund and his group, was caused by a small group of extremists in the House...

Christina Kaufman | York Dispatch 16 Oct 2013 Hits:424 Pennsylvania

Read more

Pennsylvania’s Voter ID Law Will Not Be Enforced While Trial Judge Deliberates

Pennsylvania’s Voter ID Law Will Not Be Enforced While Trial Judge Deliberates

Pennsylvania voters will not have to show photo identification at the polls until the Commonwealth Court makes a final decision in the lawsuit challenging the controversial law. Commonwealth Court Judge Bernard L. McGinley issued an order on August 16th extending the preliminary injunction of the voter ID law until the trial court makes a decision on a permanent injunction. That decision, which is separate from today’s ruling, is not expected until later this year. “We are very pleased that hundreds of thousands of eligible voters will be able to cast...

Sara Mullen | PA ACLU 16 Aug 2013 Hits:495 Pennsylvania

Read more

Pennsylvania Court Deals Blow to Secrecy-Obsessed Fracking Industry: Corporations Not The …

Pennsylvania Court Deals Blow to Secrecy-Obsessed Fracking Industry: Corporations Not The Same As Persons With Privacy Rights

“In the absence of state law, business entities are nothing.” A Pennsylvania judge in the heart of the Keystone State’s fracking belt has issued a forceful and precedent-setting decision holding that there is no corporate right to privacy under that state’s constitution, giving citizens and journalists a powerful tool to understand the health and environmental impacts of natural gas drilling in their communities. “Whether a right of privacy for businesses exists within the prenumbral rights of Pennsylvania’s constitution is a matter of first impression,” wrote Washington County Court of Common Pleas Judge...

Steven Rosenfeld | AlterNet 12 Apr 2013 Hits:494 Pennsylvania

Read more

Pa. Republicans have a Plan B to steal the 2016 presidential election

Pa. Republicans have a Plan B to steal the 2016 presidential election

They just won't quit, will they? The New Castle News (where I get most of my information these days*) is reporting that Harrisburg legislative powerhouse Sen. Dominic Pileggi has yet another scheme in which Pennsylvania would award a number of electoral votes to the losing candidate under a system not used in any of the other 49 states. As you may know, the losing candidate in every presidential election in Pennsylvania since 1988 has been a Republican. In 2012, President Obama got just under 52 percent of the popular vote and...

Will Bunch | Philly.com 05 Feb 2013 Hits:633 Pennsylvania

Read more

Pennsylvania Republicans To Introduce New Election-Rigging Plan

Last month, Republican National Committee Chair Reince Priebus called up “states that have been consistently blue that are fully controlled red” to rig future presidential elections by changing the way electoral votes are allocated. Under Priebus’ proposal, blue states such as Michigan, Wisconsin and Pennsylvania would stop awarding electoral votes to the winner of the state as a whole, and instead would award them one-by-one to the winner of each congressional district. Meanwhile, red states would continue to award 100 percent of their...

Ian Milhiser | Think Progress - Justice 04 Feb 2013 Hits:778 Pennsylvania

Read more

Hershey's Charity for Children Became GOP Slush Fund

Hershey's Charity for Children Became GOP Slush Fund

Milton and Catherine Hershey signed the deed of trust establishing the Milton Hershey School as an orphanage in 1909, funding it with revenue from the famous candy company. Since then, the school has officially been dedicated to “the purpose of nurturing and educating children in need.” Because its founder gave MHS Trust a controlling interest in the Hershey Company, today it boasts a massive $8.5 billion in assets and also owns Hershey Entertainment & Resorts (operating hotels and an amusement park). In keeping...

F Frederic Fouad | The Nation 20 Oct 2012 Hits:1267 Pennsylvania

Read more

On the Road With Working America

On the Road With Working America

One September night in the western Pennsylvania borough of Monaca, a disillusioned resident told a labor canvasser that he’d once “backed all of the Democrats all the way through,” only to realize “both sides” were “really full of shit.” Then he said something I heard often during my week in the region: “If all these factories were still running here, we’d all still have jobs.” In the mostly white, once unionized, postindustrial towns around Pittsburgh, outsourcing casts a long shadow over undecided or uninspired ...

Josh Eidelson | The Nation 11 Oct 2012 Hits:566 Pennsylvania

Read more

Judge blocks enforcement of portion of Pa. voter ID law

 Judge blocks enforcement of portion of Pa. voter ID law

HARRISBURG -- A judge has blocked the state from discounting ballots cast next month by voters who lack the photo identification required under the new voter ID law. Voters will be asked for their identification at the polls, but will vote by normal procedures and their vote will count regardless of whether they have an ID, according to officials on both sides of the case. Commonwealth Court Judge Robert Simpson wrote in an order released this morning that the injunction would have the effect of...

Karen Langley | Pittsburgh Post-Gazette 02 Oct 2012 Hits:577 Pennsylvania

Read more

Pennsylvania Voter ID Law Ruling: Judge Halts Enforcement Of Law For Election

Pennsylvania Voter ID Law Ruling: Judge Halts Enforcement Of Law For Election

A Pennsylvania judge on Tuesday postponed the enforcement of the state's new strict voter ID requirement until after the November presidential election. In a much-anticipated ruling, Commonwealth Court Judge Robert E. Simpson Jr. ordered that voters without government-issued photo ID should be allowed to cast regular ballots. "That's a huge win," said Witold J. Walczak, an attorney with the ACLU of Pennsylvania, "because last week the judge was suggesting that he was going to have every [voter without ID] vote provisionally." At the same time, the...

Dan Froomkin | Huffington Post 02 Oct 2012 Hits:662 Pennsylvania

Read more

PA Voter ID Hearing Report

PA Voter ID Hearing Report

Commonwealth promises that this time they really, really mean it when they say every voter will be able to get ID. Today’s hearing was déjà vu all over again, as the saying goes. Once again the Commonwealth produced a last-minute new ID procedure right before trial – this time literally the night before. And once again the Commonwealth asked the court to rely solely on its assurances that the new IDs would ensure that all eligible voters will get to vote in November. The biggest news of the trial (also announced in...

Sara Mullen, Associate Director, ACLU of Pennsylvania 26 Sep 2012 Hits:701 Pennsylvania

Read more

Tea Party Threatens Revenge Against Pennsylvania Justices For Not Upholding Voter ID Law

Tea  Party Threatens Revenge Against Pennsylvania Justices For Not Upholding Voter ID Law

Earlier this week, every single sitting Pennsylvania Supreme Court justice rejected a lower court decision allowing that state’s voter ID law to take effect. Four justices joined a majority opinion requiring the lower court judge to look at the case again due to concerns that voters were unable to obtain the IDs they were supposed to have easy access to as a matter of law, and two more justices joined a dissent arguing that the law should simply be suspended right away. Three of the justices in...

Ian Millhiser | Think Progress Justice 22 Sep 2012 Hits:999 Pennsylvania

Read more

Pennsylvania Voter ID Law Hits Roadblock as Court Orders Review of Decision

Pennsylvania Voter ID Law Hits Roadblock as Court Orders Review of Decision

State Supreme Court sends decision back to lower court The Pennsylvania Supreme Court on Tuesday has ordered the lower court to revisit its decision in the controversial voter ID law, which voting rights advocates have said would have disenfranchised as many as 750,000. The ruling stated: The court is to consider whether the procedures being used for deployment of the cards comport with the requirement of liberal access which the General Assembly attached to the issuance of PennDOT identification cards. If they do not, or if the Commonwealth Court is not still convinced in...

Common Dreams Staff | Common Dreams 19 Sep 2012 Hits:870 Pennsylvania

Read more

What I Spent to Comply With Pennsylvania’s New Voter ID Law

What I Spent to Comply With Pennsylvania’s New Voter ID Law

This past winter I moved to Philadelphia from Washington, D.C., where I had lived for about 3.5 years. I never bothered to register to vote down there, since the District doesn’t have voting representation at the federal level. (Yes, reader: The denizens of our nation’s capital live in a world of taxation without representation. They even slapped the phrase on their license plates in protest.) So for the interim I sent absentee ballots back home, even though they couldn’t have meant much in true-blue New...

Matt Bevilacqua | Next American City 12 Sep 2012 Hits:3884 Pennsylvania

Read more

Pa. Voter ID Law Leads to DMV Trips from 'Hell'

Pa. Voter ID Law Leads to DMV Trips from 'Hell'

Two government offices, three hour-long lines, two 78-mile trips, two week-long waiting periods, four forms of identity and two signed affidavits later, Pennsylvanians will be allowed to vote. Under the state's new voter ID laws,, which require every voter to show a government-issued photo ID at the polls, that is the epic process thousands of native Pennsylvanians have to go through to get the ID required to cast their ballots in November. And they now have just 56 days to complete it before the...

Amy Bingham | ABC News 12 Sep 2012 Hits:1103 Pennsylvania

Read more

LIVE on Sept. 13: Supreme Court Redistricting and Voter ID arguments

LIVE on Sept. 13: Supreme Court Redistricting and Voter ID arguments

The Supreme Court of Pennsylvania today announced that its entire Sept. 13 oral argument session, which includes hearings on the state’s second legislative redistricting plan and the voter ID law, will be televised live on PCN. The hearings are being held in the court’s Philadelphia City Hall courtroom. Oral arguments will begin at 9:30 a.m. in the Supreme Court’s Philadelphia courtroom, room 456 of City Hall. Strict decorum will be observed. Because of limited seating, observers will be admitted on a first come, first...

Diana Robinson | PCNTV 27 Aug 2012 Hits:794 Pennsylvania

Read more

Anti-Fracking Residents Follow and Confront Pennsylvania Gov. Tom Corbett as He Kayaks Dow…

Anti-Fracking Residents Follow and Confront Pennsylvania Gov. Tom Corbett as He Kayaks Down Endangered River in Tourism Photo Promo

Posted every few miles on the river's banks were groups of protestors, challenging the governor's pro-drilling policy with signs and chants. At just after  8 am on Thursday, Pennsylvania Gov. Tom Corbett got into a blue kayak in Beach Lake, Pa  to begin a 15 mile trip south on the scenic Delaware, the nation's most pristine and ancient river. Some 30 kayakers, friends and associates, including Richard Allan, Pennsylvania's Secretary of Conservation and Natural Resources, on the misty morning, part of a two-day promotion...

Nora Eisenberg | AlterNet 24 Aug 2012 Hits:1064 Pennsylvania

Read more

Commonwealth of Pennsylvania Settles National Voter Registration Act Case

Commonwealth of Pennsylvania Settles National Voter Registration Act Case

On Wednesday, the Black Political Empowerment Project (B-PEP) and ACTION United entered a Court approved Settlement Agreement with the Secretary of the Commonwealth Carol Aichele, Secretary of Public Welfare Gary D. Alexander, and Secretary of Health Dr. Eli N. Avila resolving claims relative to the Commonwealth’s compliance with the National Voter Registration Act (NVRA).  Since its 1993 enactment, the NVRA has helped ensure that low-income residents receive an opportunity to register to vote by mandating that all public assistance agencies offer voter...

DEMOS 23 Aug 2012 Hits:1134 Pennsylvania

Read more

Pennsylvania is Just the Latest Ruling Upholding Voter ID Law

Pennsylvania is Just the Latest Ruling Upholding Voter ID Law

 On Wednesday, in a closely watched case, a state judge in Pennsylvania declined to block the state’s controversial voter ID law from taking effect. If the ruling is upheld on appeal, registered voters in the state will be required to show acceptable photo ID during the general election in November. There’s been a lot of attention on this lawsuit, given the closeness of the election and greater focus on voter ID laws, which critics say could disenfranchise voters who are likely to lack photo ID, often the poor, elderly, and minorities....

Suevon Lee | ProPublica 17 Aug 2012 Hits:812 Pennsylvania

Read more

Pennsylvania Judge Keeps Voter ID Law Intact on Its Way to Higher Court

 Pennsylvania Judge Keeps Voter ID Law Intact on Its Way to Higher Court

A Pennsylvania judge on Wednesday declined to block a new state law requiring specific kinds of photo identification to vote. Liberal groups, arguing that minorities and the poor would be disproportionately deprived of the ballot, said they would appeal to the State Supreme Court to stop the law before the November elections. The groups said the law, like those recently passed in 10 other states, was a Republican attempt to suppress participation of the less privileged, who tend to vote for Democrats. The laws’ backers...

Ethan Bronner | New York Times 17 Aug 2012 Hits:659 Pennsylvania

Read more

Direct from Beaver County Blue

PDA In Your State

PDA 10th Anniversary - Join us in Northampton on May 10th

Speakers-Combo

Join Jim Hightower, Tom Hayden, Ben Day, Mimi Kennedy,
Thom Hartmann, Cole Stangler, Medea Benjamin, Andrea Miller
Rep. Jim McGovern, Tim Carpenter, Mark Dudzic and
John Nichols

 Buttons-PurchaseTickets

PDA Issues

PDA is organized around several core issues. These issues include:

Each team hosts a monthly conference call. Calls feature legislators, staffers and other policy experts. On these calls we determine PDA legislation to support as well as actions and future events.

Pennsylvania Leadership


For support in organizing within your state, contact:


Randy_Shannon
Walter Ebmeyer
             Randy Shannon

 

State Leadership
Walter Ebmeyer and Randy Shannon

Email us at: pennsylvania@pdamerica.org

Chapters

Beaver County
Delaware and Montgomery Counties
Lower Bucks
McConnellsburg
Philadelphia

 Want to bring progressive change to Pennsylvania? Start a PDA chapter; send us an email and we'll get you started.


PA Legislators with ALEC Ties

House of Representatives

Senate

Full List of Legislators Who Have Cut Ties With ALEC

  • Rep. Ted Harhai (D-58) - Harhai announced in May 2012 that he is no longer an ALEC member[15]
  • Rep. Kate Harper (R-61) - Harper announced in April 2012 that she is no longer an ALEC member[16]
  • Rep. William Keller (D-184) - Keller announced in May 2012 that he is no longer an ALEC member[15]
  • Rep. Nick Kotik (D-45) - Kotik announced in May 2012 that he is no longer an ALEC member[15]
  • Rep. Sandra Major (R-111) - Major announced in April 2012 that she does not plan to renew her ALEC membership[16]
  • Rep. Joseph Markosek (D-25) - Markosek announced in May 2012 that he is no longer an ALEC member[15]
  • Rep. Nicholas Micozzie (R-163) - Micozzie announced in May 2012 that he is no longer an ALEC member[15]
  • Rep. Mark Mustio (R-44) - Mustio announced in April 2012 that he is no longer an ALEC member[16]
  • Rep. Joseph Petrarca (D-55) - Petrarca told Politics PA in May 202 that he "has no ties and has never been a member of ALEC.”[17]
  • Rep. Harry Readshaw (D-36) - Readshaw claimed in April 2012 that he was never an ALEC member[16]
  • Rep. Curtis Thomas (D-181) - Thomas announced in May 2012 that he was cutting ties to ALEC.[18]
  • Rep. Mike Turzai (R-28) - Turzai told the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette in March 2012 that he is no longer an ALEC member[19]

Senate

  • Sen. Lisa Boscola (D-18) - Boscola announced in May 2012 that she is no longer an ALEC member[15]
  • Sen. Jacob Corman (R-34) - Corman announced in May 2012 that he is no longer an ALEC member[18]
  • Sen. Stewart Greenleaf (R-12) - Greenleaf told Keystone Progress in May 2012 that "I have a membership with ALEC but because of concerns that have [been] raised by my constituents I will not be renewing it."[20]
  • Sen. John Pippy (R-37) - Pippy's staff announced in April 2012 that he is no longer an ALEC member[16]
  • Sen. Leanna Washington (D-4) - Washington announced in May 2012 that she is no longer an ALEC member[15]
  • Sen. Anthony Williams (D-8) - Williams, who has used PA state funding for ALEC,[21] "vociferously protested being identified with ALEC," according to Keystone Progress. "As a staunch advocate for school choice, I’m often invited to attend and speak at myriad events, locally and nationally, held by those who share my beliefs and those who vigorously oppose them. I make no apologies for my views on choice, because a broad set of educational options is among the best hopes students have to attain the skills needed to be productive and competitive in a global, 21st century society. However, I’ve never sought membership in the American Legislative Exchange Council nor have I ever been a member,” said Williams. “Lastly, ALEC does not represent my values or beliefs.”[15]
Information from Sourcewatch:

Events from Main Line Peace Action

PR Rank