Texas In Planned Parenthood vs. Texas, Judicial Whiplash Ensues

TX-PlannedParenthood

On Monday afternoon an Austin-based federal judge told the Texas Health and Human Services department that it couldn’t exclude Planned Parenthood from the state’s Women’s Health Program (WHP). Issuing a temporary injunction, U.S. District Judge Lee Yeakel—a George W. Bush appointee—wrote that disqualifying Planned Parenthood from the program is a likely infringement on the constitutional rights of WHP users to choose their reproductive health provider.

The victory was short-lived: By about midnight on Monday, Texas attorney general Greg Abbott had filed an appeal and secured an emergency stay from Judge Jerry Smith of the 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in New Orleans. Planned Parenthood opposed the stay yesterday evening; Smith will consider it as he decides on the state’s appeal.

For the time being, it seems that many women won’t be able to use WHP at Planned Parenthood to get their no- or low-cost pap smears, breast exams, birth control, STI screening and treatment, blood pressure and cholesterol screenings and other healthcare. Currently, WHP serves more than 100,000 women who can demonstrate that they are at or below 185 percent of the federal poverty limit (translation: a monthly income of $1,723 for a single, childless woman; $2,333 for a household of two; $2,294 for three people; and $3,533 for four). Planned Parenthood serves 40 percent of these clients and is the single largest provider in the state.

This latest skirmish began in mid-April when Texas-based Planned Parenthood affiliates that don’t perform abortions sued the state to stop a law Republicans passed in late February that would make them ineligible for WHP because they share a name with clinics that offer the procedure. The plaintiffs argue that they are legally and financially separate from those that perform abortions (which are still legal, by the way); that WHP patients have a right to choose where they get their healthcare (duh); and that many will not have a viable alternative to Planned Parenthood.

In his 25-page decision, Yeakel seemed to agree, writing, “The record demonstrates that plaintiffs currently provide a critical component of Texas’ family-planning services to low-income women. The court is unconvinced that Texas will be able to find substitute providers for these women in the immediate future, despite its stated intention to do so.”

Indeed, Texas has the highest rate of uninsured people in the country and 35 percent of women ages 15 to 44 are not covered. Last year, the governor slashed its Medicaid budget by two thirds. And in March, Governor Rick Perry turned down $35 million in federal funds that underwrite WHP because the Obama administration (rightly) refused to let him cut Planned Parenthood from its network of providers on ideological grounds. Since then, the cash-strapped state has been claiming that it will fully fund the WHP using its own dollars.

Advocates aren’t so optimistic: “In an effort to target Planned Parenthood and drive them out of Texas, everybody else has been caught in the net,” Fran Hagerty, CEO of the Women’s Health and Family Planning Association of Texas, told me in a mid-March interview. “They’re throwing the baby out with the bathwater. I have been telling [conservative legislators] for years that if they keep doing what they’re doing, we’re going to end up with no family planning providers except Planned Parenthood because they’re so well-supported and do such a bang-up job of getting national and local support.”

While the Planned Parenthood brand is well known and draws lots of supporters, Texas branches that serve poor, rural, mostly Latino areas are suffering acutely. In Hidalgo County, for example, four centers along the Mexican border have shut down since the end of the 82nd Legislative Session last September.

In a tone-deaf statement issued on Monday, Governor Rick Perry’s press secretary said that the state is primarily concerned about the life and liberty of its residents.

“Texas has a long history of protecting life, and we are confident in Attorney General Abbott’s appeal to defend the will of Texans and our state law, which prohibits taxpayer funds from supporting abortion providers and affiliates in the Women’s Health Program. We will continue to work with the Attorney General to pursue all available legal options.”

I’d love to see them say that to the WHP enrollees, who often use Planned Parenthood as their sole source of healthcare. As the late, great Whitney Houston famously said, “Show me some receipts.”

Stay tuned for periodic updates in this quickly evolving case.

Link to original article from ColorLines


blog comments powered by Disqus

States - Texas

Texas Articles

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
Prev Next

Texas House Approves 12 Firearms Bills To Put More Guns In Classrooms And Defy Federal Law

Texas House Approves 12 Firearms Bills To Put More Guns In Classrooms And Defy Federal Law

On Saturday, as Texas hosted the National Rifle Association’s annual convention, the Texas House passed 12 gun bills to make it even easier to obtain and possess firearms in the state. The onslaught of legislation contains provisions to allow college students to carry handguns in class and to block any theoretical federal bans on assault weapons or high-capacity ammunition. The 12 bills, a veritable goody bag for gun rights advocates, passed easily in the Republican-dominated House. Texas lawmakers introduced about twice as many gun bills this session as last year, generally...

Aviva Shen | ThinkProgress 06 May 2013 Hits:344 Texas

Read more

Texas Teachers Personally Lobby Lawmakers

Texas Teachers Personally Lobby Lawmakers

Texas teachers were up early on the first day of spring break working on their lesson plan.  But it wasn't for their students.   The educators need to convince budget-conscious lawmakers that last session's cuts in school funding need to be restored.  They hope to put a human face on the problem of overworked classroom teachers and how it's affecting our children. Montserrat Garibay with the teachers’ group Education Austin says, "Unfortunately many of these legislators have never been in a classroom so educating them is very important to us...

Fred Cantu | KEYE-TV 13 Mar 2013 Hits:769 Texas

Read more

Dallas legislator aims to stop wage requirements in incentive deals

Dallas legislator aims to stop wage requirements in incentive deals

Texas lawmakers are stepping into a debate about whether Austin should require companies to pay a “living wage” to construction workers to qualify for economic development deals. State Rep. Kenneth Sheets, R-Dallas, said a group of minority contractors told him they would have difficulty paying the $11-an-hour living wage to the laborers they hire, making those contractors less likely to get a piece of the publicly subsidized projects. Sheets filed legislation last month that would bar cities from mandating any wage requirements as part of economic incentive packages, such as the ones...

Tony Plohetski and Marty Toohey | The Statesman 05 Mar 2013 Hits:657 Texas

Read more

At Capitol, fight is on to expand Medicaid

At Capitol, fight is on to expand Medicaid

Adamantly opposed to expanding Medicaid coverage under President Barack Obama’s signature health care law, Gov. Rick Perry and Lt. Gov. David Dewhurst had seemingly squelched efforts this legislative session to insure an additional 1.1 million low-income Texans under the Affordable Care Act. But a determined campaign, targeting legislators with public pressure and private persuasion, has kept the issue alive by framing Medicaid expansion as an economic bonanza and tax-relief opportunity that would bring $79 billion in much-needed federal money over 10 years. The arguments, pitched to Republican ears, have carved out a...

Chuck Lindell | American-Statesman 18 Feb 2013 Hits:640 Texas

Read more

Paint it Blue! Democrats Launch Plan to Take Back Texas

Paint it Blue! Democrats Launch Plan to Take Back Texas

The party is launching a full-scale offensive in the Lone Star with the aim of slowly turning the GOP stronghold into a battleground state Democrats, bolstered by President Obama’s victory last fall, have now set their sights on a prize even more valuable than the White House: the state of Texas. The party is launching a full-scale offensive in the Lone Star with the aim of slowly turning the GOP stronghold into a battleground state. According to Politico, a coalition of groups is creating a grassroots...

Laura Gottesdiener | AlterNet 01 Feb 2013 Hits:704 Texas

Read more

Texas is thinking about giving its oil and gas inspectors guns

Texas is thinking about giving its oil and gas inspectors guns

This is the kind of story that people look back on after a tragedy and say: Well, that was a bad idea. The Texas Railroad Commission, which regulates oil and gas development, is considering arming its employees. From NPR: In announcing his initiative, [Commission Chair Barry] Smitherman cited “recent shooting tragedies around the country”. In response to questions from StateImpact, he elaborated in an email: “At the Railroad Commission, many of our employees -- such as our field inspectors -- often work alone in remote, desolate areas of...

Philip Bump | Grist.org 30 Jan 2013 Hits:317 Texas

Read more

Texas Legislature Wants To Reward Companies That Deny Employees Contraception

Texas Legislature Wants To Reward Companies That Deny Employees Contraception

A bill recently introduced in the Texas state house aims to reward employers who violate Obamacare, offering subsidies to any company that uses religious objection as an excuse for denying its employees copay-free contraception. House Bill 649, introduced by state Rep. Jonathan Stickland (R), was apparently inspired by the controversy over craft chain store Hobby Lobby. That store sued to deny its employees contraception coverage, citing its male president’s religious objections. But since Hobby Lobby, and companies like it, will be forced to pay a fine for violating...

Annie-Rose Strasser | ThinkProgress 29 Jan 2013 Hits:390 Texas

Read more

Nurses Mark Five Years of Collective Bargaining, Quality Care in TX

Nurses Mark Five Years of Collective Bargaining, Quality Care in TX

Registered Nurses, members of the National Nurses Organizing Committee-Texas/National Nurses United (NNU) -- the largest union and professional association of registered nurses in the country, with 185,000 members -- will rally outside Cypress Fairbanks Medical Center (11049 FM 1940, Houston, corner of Steepletop and FM 1960)  on Thursday, January 24 at Noon, to celebrate an important anniversary: five years of collective bargaining -- and the quality patient care those contracts provide --in the state’s private sector hospitals. “What you see in our hospitals is...

26 Jan 2013 Hits:938 Texas

Read more

A Major Win for Nurses in Texas

A Major Win for Nurses in Texas

More than 1,500 Texas nurses won new contracts through their first ever collective bargaining agreement yesterday. They joined National Nurses United, which is the argest union of registered nurses in the country. "Texas took a big step forward in terms of patient care standards with these agreements," said Fred Flores, RN, of Corpus Christi Medical Center’s Emergency Department. The announcement comes only weeks after thousands of Houston janitors went on strike for weeks, demanding that the city raise the minimum wage. The nurses new contracts...

Laura Gottesdiener | AlterNet 07 Sep 2012 Hits:608 Texas

Read more

Victory for Texas Voters as Court Halts GOP Redistricting Plan

Victory for Texas Voters as Court Halts GOP Redistricting Plan

A federal court on Tuesday agreed with the Department of Justice that redistricted voter maps in Texas did not comply with the 1965 Voting Rights Act, and that the effort by the Republican-controlled state legislature was an attempt to deprive or diminish the ability of minorities -- most Latinos -- of their right to an election free of racial discrimination. Three separate maps, for new districts for the US House and the Texas Senate and House, violated the Voting Rights Act, according to the three-judge panel...

Common Dreams Staff 29 Aug 2012 Hits:556 Texas

Read more

Court: Texas can cut off Planned Parenthood funds

Court: Texas can cut off Planned Parenthood funds

A federal appeals court ruled late Tuesday that Texas can cut off funding for Planned Parenthood clinics that provide health services to low-income women before a trial over a new law that bans state money from going to organizations tied to abortion providers. The 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in New Orleans lifted a federal judge's temporary injunction that called for the funding to continue pending an October trial on Planned Parenthood's challenge to the law. State officials sought to cut off funding to Planned Parenthood...

Will Weissert | AP 23 Aug 2012 Hits:473 Texas

Read more

This Week in Poverty: Here's to the Houston Janitors

This Week in Poverty: Here's to the Houston Janitors

Last week, more than 3,200 janitors in Houston called an end to their five-week strike. The cleaning contractors initially offered a total wage increase of $.50 an hour phased in over five years—so in 2016 the janitors would earn $8.85 an hour. The janitors asked for a raise to $10 an hour over three years. In the end, the janitors accepted $9.35 an hour over four years, a 12 percent increase over their current pay. They also fought off an effort by the contractors that would have allowed...

Greg Kaufman | The Nation 17 Aug 2012 Hits:542 Texas

Read more

Tea Party Favorite Wins GOP Runoff in Texas

Tea Party Favorite Wins GOP Runoff in Texas

Score another victory for the Tea Party. One-time long-shot candidate Ted Cruz completed his once nearly unthinkable upset Tuesday, winning the runoff for the Republican Senate nomination in Texas over David Dewhurst, the state's lieutenant governor who had the backing of Rick Perry and a vast personal fortune behind his bid. Cruz's win makes him the overwhelming favorite to win this November's general election for the Senate seat currently held by Republican Sen. Kay Bailey Hutchison, who will retire at the end of this term. The Tea Party-favorite will now face off...

Josh Voorhees | Slate.com 01 Aug 2012 Hits:457 Texas

Read more

Perry's Medicaid move will cost us plenty

Perry's Medicaid move will cost us plenty

Are you willing to pay more taxes and higher health insurance premiums so Gov. Rick Perry and other Republicans can try to score points against President Obama? Never mind. No need to ask. You don't have a choice. Perry already decided you will pay more. He's refusing to participate in Medicaid expansion completely paid for by the federal government. His decision means local taxpayers are going to get stuck with another big tab. When health care services are offered to a person who can't afford to...

Glen W. Smith | Chron.com 11 Jul 2012 Hits:723 Texas

Read more

Texas Republican Party Calls For Abstinence Only Sex Ed, Corporal Punishment In Schools

Texas Republican Party Calls For Abstinence Only Sex Ed, Corporal Punishment In Schools

Early this month, Texas Republican delegates met in Fort Worth to approve their 2012 platform, notable parts of which take aim at the state's education system. In the section titled "Educating Our Children," the document states that "corporal punishment is effective" and recommends teachers be given "more authority" to deal with disciplinary problems. Additionally, the document states the party opposes mandatory pre-school and kindergarten, saying parents are "best suited to train their children in their early development." The position causing the most controversy, however, is the statement that...

Laura Hibbard | Huffington Post 30 Jun 2012 Hits:712 Texas

Read more

Direct from Occupy Dallas

PDA In Your State

Issue Team Calls

Tue May 21, 2013 @ 9:00PM - 10:00PM
Healthcare for All Issue Team Call
(559) 726-1300; Access Code: 733525#
Wed May 22, 2013 @ 9:00PM - 10:00PM
End Corporate Rule IOT Call
(559) 726-1300; Access Code: 754227#
Mon May 27, 2013 @ 9:00PM - 10:00PM
PDA ERA 3 State Strategy Call
(559) 726-1300; Access Code: 787085#
Tue May 28, 2013 @ 9:00PM - 10:00PM
Clean, Fair, Transparent Elections IOT Call
(559) 726-1300; Access Code: 314363#
Wed Jun 05, 2013 @ 9:00PM - 10:00PM
Economic and Social Justice Issue Team Call
(559) 726-1300; Access Code: 781761#
Mon Jun 10, 2013 @ 8:30PM - 09:30PM
End Mass Criminalizations IOT Call
(559) 726-1300; Access Code: 331473#
Tue Jun 11, 2013 @ 9:00PM - 10:00PM
End Wars and Occupations Issue Team Call
(559) 726-1300; Access Code: 952870#
Tue Jun 18, 2013 @ 9:00PM - 10:00PM
Healthcare for All Issue Team Call
(559) 726-1300; Access Code: 733525#
Wed Jun 19, 2013 @ 9:00PM - 10:00PM
Stop Global Warming Issue Team Call
(559) 726-1300; Access Code: 661274#
Mon Jun 24, 2013 @ 9:00PM - 10:00PM
PDA ERA 3 State Strategy Call
(559) 726-1300; Access Code: 787085#

PDA Issues

PDA is organized around several core issues. These issues include:

Each team hosts a monthly conference call. Calls feature legislators, staffers and other policy experts. On these calls we determine PDA legislation to support as well as actions and future events.

Texas Leadership

For support in organizing within your state, contact:



Robbie Byrd

 

State Leadership
Robbie Byrd

Email us at: texas@pdamerica.org

Chapters

El Paso

Planned Chapters
Austin
Brownsville
Dallas
Houston
San Antonio 

Want to bring progressive change to Texas? Start a PDA chapter; send us an email and we'll get you started.


Texas Facebook

TX Legislators with ALEC Ties

House of Representatives

Senate

Legislators Who Have Cut Ties With ALEC

  • Rep. Alma Allen (D-131) - Allen said in a statement to the organization "Progress Texas," "As a legislator, I value the input that non-partisan organizations contribute to various issues. However, I do not believe that the American Legislative Exchange Council is a non-partisan organization. Due to the legislation that ALEC has been involved in forming and promoting, I will not be renewing my membership. I value and listen to all opinions, but ALEC's agenda has become harmful to my constituents, and the people of the State of Texas."[25]
  • Rep. Armando Martinez (D-Weslaco) - Announced he would not be renewing his ALEC membership in April 2012.[26]
  • Rep. Dawnna Dukes (D-Austin) - Announced she would not be renewing her ALEC membership in April 2012.[26]
  • Rep. Hubert Vo (D-Houston) - Announced he would not be renewing his ALEC membership in April 2012.[26]
  • Rep. Harold Dutton (D-Houston) - Announced he would not be renewing his ALEC membership in April 2012.[26]
  • Rep. Chente Quintanilla (D-Tornillo) - Announced he would not be renewing his ALEC membership in April 2012.[26]
  • Rep. Eddie Rodriguez (D-Austin) - Announced he would not be renewing his ALEC membership in April 2012.[26]
  • Rep. José Menéndez (D-San Antonio) - Announced he would not be renewing his ALEC membership in April 2012.[26]
  • Rep. Ruth Jones McClendon (D-San Antonio) - Announced she would not be renewing her ALEC membership in April 2012.[26]
  • Rep. Eric Johnson (D-Dallas) - Announced he would not be renewing his ALEC membership in April 2012.[26]
  • Rep. Tracy O. King (D-80) - Announced he would not be renewing his ALEC membership in April 2012.[26]
  • Rep. Ryan Guillen (D-31) - Announced he would not be renewing his ALEC membership in April 2012.[27]
Information from Sourcewatch:

PR Rank